Exclusive leads vs shared leads: what is the difference in money?
A shared lead is sold to three or four companies at the same time. It pushes your close rate down from around 20 to around 5 percent, forces you to compete on price instead of quality, and often makes the cost per won job higher even though the lead itself was cheaper.
Most home improvement companies have tried a lead marketplace. The model is simple: you pay a low amount per lead and you get a lot of them. What rarely appears in large print is that the same lead was also sold to your competitors.
Here is what the sharing actually costs, and when exclusivity is worth the money.
What happens when four companies call the same homeowner
The homeowner fills in a form and gets four calls within an hour. The first thing she learns is that her enquiry is a product that has been traded. The second thing she learns is that she can play the four quotes against each other.
From that moment the conversation is no longer about who does the best work. It is about price. And the company that wins is usually the one that cut deepest into its own margin.
Speed becomes more important than quality
On a marketplace, who calls first decides everything. That means your whole sales process gets rebuilt around being fast rather than being thorough, and you have to staff the phone in a way most smaller companies cannot.
Call 20 minutes after the other three and the lead is effectively spent. You still paid for it.
The maths behind the two models
Take a window company with an $11,000 average job and a 30 percent gross margin. That is $3,300 in margin per job.
With shared leads at $30 and a 5 percent close rate, you need 20 leads per job. That is $600 in lead cost, plus 20 calls and maybe five drives. With exclusive, verified quote appointments at $260 and a 25 percent close rate, you need four appointments per job. That is $1,040, but only four drives and four conversations.
- Shared leads: lower cost per lead, lower close rate, more drives, more wasted sales time
- Exclusive appointments: higher cost per lead, higher close rate, fewer drives, a better starting point in the conversation
- The number to compare on is always total cost per won job, never cost per lead
When do shared leads actually make sense?
They make sense if you have a large and cheap call centre, a very short sales process and a low job value where volume matters more than conversion.
For most companies selling roofing, windows, kitchens or bathrooms, that description does not fit. There, the job value is high enough that every single conversation is worth doing properly.
Key takeaways
- Shared leads move the conversation from quality to price before you even arrive
- Close rate on shared leads typically sits around 5 percent against 20 to 25 on exclusive ones
- Always compare on cost per won job, never on cost per lead
- Shared leads can work at low job value with high call capacity, rarely otherwise
Frequently asked questions
How many companies is a shared lead typically sold to?
Typically three to five. Some marketplaces state it in their terms, others do not. Ask directly and get the answer in writing.
How much does the close rate drop on a shared lead?
In practice from around 20 to 25 percent on an exclusive, verified appointment down to around 5 percent on a shared lead, depending on how fast you call.
Can I get exclusive leads without paying a retainer?
Yes. Some vendors work on performance instead of a retainer, for example a low setup fee and then a percentage of the jobs you close from their appointments. That puts most of the risk on the vendor.
What should I look for in an exclusive lead agreement?
That the exclusivity is in writing, that there is a rejection window for leads that do not meet the criteria, and that there is no lock-in beyond a short notice period.
More articles
Want more of the right kitchen and bath appointments?
We build and fund the campaign, qualify the homeowner and book exclusive appointments into your calendar. A one-time setup fee, then a percentage of the jobs you close. No retainer.
Get your price for your area →